Acquisition measurement

PROP FIRM CUSTOMER ACQUISITION COST.

Count first-time paying buyers, then compare what each acquisition group returns after refunds and payment fees.

  • By Prop Firm Marketers
What you’ll check
New paying buyers

Find each buyer’s first confirmed challenge order.

Acquisition costs

Match channel costs to the dates used to group buyers.

30-day contribution

Bring refunds, chargebacks and fees into the comparison.

COMPARE WHAT BUYERS RETURN.

  • Divide acquisition cost by first-time paying buyers assigned to the same cohort.
  • Give each buyer the same follow-up window before making comparisons.
  • Use refunds, disputes and fees to explain why the lowest CAC can return less.
ON THIS PAGE
  1. 01Define the buyer cohort
  2. 02Prepare the inputs
  3. 03Calculate and compare
  4. 04Use it in a channel review
  5. 05Sources

To calculate customer acquisition cost for a prop firm, divide acquisition spend by the number of new buyers whose first challenge payment was confirmed. Compare channels on comparable buyer groups, then check what those buyers paid and what your firm returned within the same follow-up period. This works from your order records even when ad platforms report different attributed sales totals.

01Define the buyer cohort

COUNT FIRST-TIME BUYERS ONCE

Customer acquisition cost is the cost of acquiring first-time paying buyers divided by the number acquired. For a prop firm, a first-time buyer is someone with their first confirmed paid challenge order. Use a stable internal customer ID and check all available order history. A second challenge, reset or add-on belongs to the existing customer. Label orders with incomplete history separately, especially after a migration.

Pick a weekly or monthly reporting cohort with a shared timezone, currency and attribution rule. Where you can record acquisition dates, cohort buyers by the acquisition touch you assign and allow a fixed window for their first purchase to occur. Align the cohort’s acquisition spend to those dates. If you only have purchase dates, report spend divided by buyers in the period as a directional estimate and say that some earlier spend can convert later.

Keep the source assignment consistent. GA4’s first-user source and session source refer to different moments in the customer journey, so a visitor first acquired through search can pay during an email session. Choose one rule for the operator report, carry an unknown-source group and document any gaps. See Google’s acquisition report comparison.

02Prepare the inputs

JOIN BUYERS, CHANNEL COSTS AND ORDER ADJUSTMENTS

Export paid orders and order adjustments from the same finance source. The order rows need an internal buyer reference, an order ID, payment time, programme, currency and recorded amount after coupon. For the channel table, define whether the cost includes ad spend alone, or also includes the agreed acquisition commissions, creator invoices, tooling and production costs. Record each cost in one place. Preserve original currencies and apply the same conversion convention across channels if you need a reporting currency.

  • Customer historyFind the first confirmed order for each customer before assigning the cohort. Assign the channel once with your chosen rule and retain unknowns.
  • Order revenueAdd first and repeat orders within a fixed period after first purchase. Keep discounts applied at checkout and exclude tax collected on behalf of authorities in the comparison.
  • Order adjustmentsJoin refunds, chargebacks and payment fees to the original orders. Watch for a chargeback already included in an adjustment export so you avoid counting it twice.
  • Marketing costsInclude costs by channel and cohort dates. Allocate shared costs using a documented rule or show them in a separate overall line. Treat the same commission as acquisition cost only once.

Keep refund and chargeback exceptions visible. A later refund does not erase the effort spent acquiring the buyer, so keep the buyer in your initial CAC denominator and record the money returned in the follow-up report. If you also track retained buyers, define that as a separate rate.

03Calculate and compare

COMPARE CAC WITH 30-DAY CONTRIBUTION

Set one observation window for each buyer, such as 30 days after their first purchase, then compare completed windows. First calculate CAC. Next compare net order revenue after adjustments and payment fees with the same channel’s acquisition costs. Retain the underlying counts so the team sees how much evidence each channel has.

Example · Paid social

40 new buyers · €60 CAC

€2,400 in acquisition costs ÷ 40 first-time buyers. In their first 30 days, buyers paid €4,000 excluding tax and after coupons. Subtract €720 in refunds and chargebacks, and €160 in payment fees.

€720 remaining after acquisition.

Example · Creator campaign

15 new buyers · €40 CAC

€600 in acquisition costs ÷ 15 first-time buyers. In their first 30 days, buyers paid €1,150 excluding tax and after coupons. Subtract €480 in refunds and chargebacks, and €55 in payment fees.

€15 remaining after acquisition.

The creator campaign acquired buyers for less, and the sample had more money returned per buyer. Investigate whether the customer mix, offer or buyer experience explains that difference. The example tracks acquisition contribution before operating costs. For an operating view, account for relevant programme delivery costs, rewards, support and overhead using your finance team’s definitions. Flag adjustments arriving after day 30 and revisit older cohorts when those balances move.

04Use it in a channel review

REVIEW RESULTS AT THE SAME AGE

Make a weekly table with one row per cohort and channel. Include acquisition cost, number of new buyers, CAC, first-order value, repeat revenue, refunds, chargebacks, fees and acquisition contribution. Show how many buyers have completed the observation period. For a fresher view, add a seven-day table and compare it with historical seven-day values.

  1. 01
    Check source coverage

    Keep unattributed buyers visible. Reconcile the number of buyers to your order history before comparing channels.

  2. 02
    Find the cost driver

    Check if more expensive acquisition came from campaign cost, offer mix or a lower checkout completion rate.

  3. 03
    Check the adjustments

    Separate refunds and disputes by programme and cohort before concluding a channel’s buyer quality changed.

  4. 04
    Pick a decision to review

    Write down the change, the segment it affects and when enough of the new cohort will be observable.

When the same audience might buy through email, organic search or creators, preserve the agreed channel assignment in the acquisition report. Use the channel overlap to ask better questions about incremental demand. The prop firm calculator can model an upcoming month using your own assumptions. For what already happened, compare the cohort report to the underlying orders.

SOURCE NOTES.

Documentation and examples referenced in this guide.

  1. 01Google Analytics · User acquisition and traffic acquisition reports
  2. 02Google Analytics · Explore playbook
Book a call

REVIEW YOUR ACQUISITION COST.

Bring one channel and its order totals. We’ll discuss how to compare acquisition costs with confirmed purchases and adjustments.

Book a 30-minute callFor prop firm operators planning a launch or improving an active programme.

WORTH YOUR TIME IF

  • You run a prop firm, or you are about to launch one
  • Your site, ads, search or email is not selling as it should
  • You want one team instead of four freelancers
  • You can share your numbers on the call